Law versus Custom: Can Personal Status Reforms Change Marital Practices?
Laws governing marriage and divorce have multifaceted effects on women. This article examines whether personal status law reforms can change deeply rooted marital customs, exploiting India's 2019 ban on instant triple talaq. This practice let a Muslim man unilaterally and irrevocably end a marriage by pronouncing "talaq" (divorce) three times. Using three waves of National Family Health Survey data with a difference-in-differences framework, we find that the probability of divorce among Muslim women fell slightly after the reform, but the effect vanishes among ever-married women. This is likely reflecting a shift toward other divorce forms such as khula (women-initiated divorce), sometimes prompted by husbands seeking to lower their financial obligations. A near-significant rise in spousal abandonment also emerges following the law. These findings show that prohibiting a specific practice may curb certain harms while generating unintended consequences, underscoring how legal reform often struggles to reshape marital practices embedded in social hierarchies.